No one expects to walk into a doctor’s office or hospital and leave worse off than they arrived. But sometimes, things don’t go as planned. A treatment doesn’t work. A surgery has complications. Or worse, your condition declines instead of improving. When this happens, it’s natural to wonder: Is this just bad luck, or could it be malpractice?
At Hoffman, Larin & Agnetti, we’ve helped countless clients untangle this question. And here’s the truth: not every poor medical outcome is malpractice, but some are. The key is knowing the difference—and acting quickly when something doesn’t feel right.
What Is Medical Malpractice?
Medical malpractice occurs when a healthcare provider fails to meet the accepted standard of care, harming the patient. This could be due to negligence, errors in judgment, or outright mistakes. Medical malpractice is not about whether the doctor “tried their best” or the unfavorable outcome. It’s about whether they acted in a way that a competent professional wouldn’t have under the same circumstances.
Signs Your Outcome Might Be Malpractice
If you’re wondering whether your situation qualifies as medical malpractice, look out for these red flags:
1. Lack of Informed Consent
Before any procedure, your doctor must explain the risks, benefits, and alternatives so you can make an informed decision. If you weren’t properly informed—or felt pressured into agreeing without fully understanding the risks—this could be a sign of negligence.
2. Ignored Complaints or Symptoms
Were your concerns dismissed by your doctor or medical team? If you raised red flags about worsening symptoms, pain, or complications and were ignored, this could point to a failure in proper care. Healthcare providers have a duty to listen to and address their patients’ concerns.
3. A Drastic, Unexpected Outcome
Some risks are inherent in medical procedures, and doctors typically warn you about them. But if your outcome is far worse than what you were prepared for—or entirely unrelated to your condition—it’s worth investigating whether an error was made.
4. A “Cover-Up” or Lack of Transparency
If your doctor or medical team seems evasive about what went wrong, won’t provide clear answers, or refuses to release your medical records, it might indicate that something went wrong behind the scenes.
5. A Pattern of Similar Mistakes
Do some digging into your provider’s history? Have they been sued for malpractice before? Do they have disciplinary actions or a record of complaints? Patterns of negligence can be a significant red flag.
When It’s Probably Not Malpractice
Sometimes, bad outcomes happen even when the doctor does everything right. For example:
- A patient has an allergic reaction to a medication they’ve never taken before despite proper screening.
- A procedure carries a known, unavoidable risk that unfortunately happens.
- The underlying condition was too severe to fully treat, despite the best efforts of the medical team.
In these cases, it’s more likely lousy luck than malpractice.
The Importance of a Second Opinion
Getting a second opinion is critical if you’re unsure whether your poor outcome resulted from malpractice. A fresh set of eyes from a qualified medical professional can:
- Confirm whether the original treatment plan was appropriate.
- Identify any missed diagnoses or mistakes.
- Provide valuable evidence if malpractice is suspected.
At Hoffman, Larin & Agnetti, we work with trusted medical experts who can review your case and provide insights into what went wrong.
Real-Life Examples: Malpractice or Bad Luck?
Let’s look at a couple of examples to see the difference:
Case 1: Surgery Gone Wrong
A patient undergoes a routine gallbladder surgery but wakes up with damage to their bile duct. The surgeon admits they accidentally cut the duct due to misreading an anatomical structure.
- Verdict: Malpractice. The surgeon failed to meet the standard of care by not correctly identifying the anatomy before making the incision.
Case 2: Cancer Diagnosis Delayed
A patient complains of persistent fatigue and weight loss, but their doctor dismisses it as stress. Months later, they’re diagnosed with advanced cancer that might have been treatable earlier.
- Verdict: Malpractice. The doctor failed to act on warning signs and order necessary diagnostic tests.
Case 3: Post-Surgery Complication
A patient develops an infection after a hip replacement, even though the surgeon followed all proper protocols and informed the patient of this risk beforehand.
- Verdict: Bad luck. Infections are a known risk of surgery, and no negligence occurred.
What Should You Do If You Suspect Malpractice?
If something feels off about your medical treatment, don’t ignore it. Here’s what you should do:
- Document Everything. Keep a record of symptoms, communications with providers, and any relevant paperwork.
- Request Your Medical Records. These will be essential for evaluating your case.
- Speak With an Experienced Attorney. Medical malpractice cases are complex and require expert evaluation. At Hoffman, Larin & Agnetti, we offer free consultations to help you determine your next steps. Remember we only get paid when we win your case!
Let Us Help You Get Answers
A poor medical outcome can leave you feeling confused and overwhelmed. Was it bad luck, or was it malpractice? The experienced attorneys at Hoffman, Larin & Agnetti are here to help you find out. With over 40 years of experience serving South Florida, we have the knowledge and resources to fight for the justice you deserve.
Call us today for a free consultation. Let’s get to the bottom of your case together.
Call us at 305-653-5555. Email us at [email protected]. Text us at 305-653-1515 or Fill out the form at www.hlalaw.com, and we will call you.
Our experienced medical malpractice attorneys will see you at any of our 4 offices, by phone or ZOOM, at your home, or in the hospital.
40 years fighting for the rights of Floridians!
Hoffman, Larin & Agnetti
Experience and Results Matter
